My collection of Pudge stands at 20, with his Rangers days being in my realm of collecting youth. Here are my Top 5:
1997 Upper Deck #138 (DG)
In hand, I don't like theses cards. The reflective coating damages way too easily. Going just by the scans however, the Defensive Gems in this set really stand out. The picture of Pudge looks like it's coming off the card in this scan. I love the contrast.
1992 Pinnacle #156
This set from Pinnacle does a good job of framing the pictures. I like how only part of the background is used, and the black border to make it really stand out.
1991 Bowman #272 (RC)
I prefer my cards of catchers to show them in gear. I couldn't pass up including his rookie card though. Have you seen him lately? The dude does not age!
1992 Score #700
His eyes facing forward, I'm thinking this shot was taken just after a throw to second to catch a thief. Chances are good he got the out.
2008 Upper Deck #740 (SH)
So far every card I've shown has each Hall of Famer with just one team. Bagwell only played with the Atros, and Raines was an iconic figure in Montreal. Rodriguez was known mainly during his days in Texas, but he played for a lot of teams, and most of the time he played very well. We'll close out the list with him as a Tiger.
Ivan Rodriguez was an easy choice for a first ballot Hall of Famer. Congrats, Ivan!