Friday, November 20, 2026

The All-Thanksgiving Day Team

Thanksgiving is less than a week away, and I for one am ready for it. Inspired by the "All Cooking Team" post I did earlier this year, I decided to come up with a team of players whose names would be right at home at the Thanksgiving table.
 
There's actually a lot of people online who have done their own version of this. Some names kept popping up more than others, but I took some obvious choices, found a few others of my own, and created this list. Enjoy!  
 

Catcher -  Clarence "Yam" Yaryan

1923 Zee-Nut Yam Yaryan

Yam played for 2 seasons in the 1920's with the White Sox. As far as the food goes, my wife makes this delicious sweet potato side dish with walnuts and marshmallows. 
 

1st Baseman -  Ham Hyatt

1910 American Caramel (E90-2)
Ham Hyatt
 
Not everyone eats turkey on thanksgiving. Ham is an acceptable substitute. Hamilton Hyatt was a member of the 1909 World Champion Pittsburgh Pirates.
 

2nd Baseman -  Nap Lajoie

1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes
#175 Napoleon Lajoie (LGD)

It doesn't matter if you believe the sandman visits because of a chemical in the turkey or your body reacting to an abundant buffet of delights, but there's nothing quite like that post-meal nap... Lajoie of course was not sleepy on the field, and considered one of the greatest 2nd basemen to have ever played the game.
 

Shortstop -  Bobby Wine

1963 Topps #71 Bobby Wine (RC)
 
I rarely drink anymore. If the occasion warrants it, I'm not opposed to a glass of red wine. Boby Wine was a gold glove winner for the Phillies in 1963.
 

3rd Baseman -  Pie Traynor

1991 Conlon Collection TSN
#36 Pie Traynor (HOF)
 
What's your favorite pie? For me, it's a tough choice between pumpkin and dutch apple. (Ok, I'm purposely focusing on holiday favorites - peanut butter pie is my actual favorite!)  Traynor's nickname actually came during his childhood years. He often visited a grocery store and asked for pie. The store owner called him "Pie Face", which his friends later shortened to Pie.
 

Outfielder - Ty Cobb

1973 Topps
#475 The All-Time Batting Leader - Ty Cobb (ATL)
 
Off the cob or on, corn is a staple Thanksgiving side dish. Ty Cobb, despite being a great player, was an a$$ both off and on the field.
  

Outfielder - Turkey Stearnes

2005 Helmar Brewing Famous Athletes
#66 Turkey Stearnes
 
No other food represents Thanksgiving as much as turkey! My father-in-law fries one every year, and that crispy skin makes a world of difference! This Hall of Famer is the Negro League's all-time home run hitter, leading the league in homers 7 times between 1924-1940.
 

Outfielder - Damian Rolls

2004 Topps #603 Damian Rolls
 
There's nothing like a warm buttered roll! Damian was a 1996 1st round pick who spent 5 years in Tampa. 
 

Designated Hitter - Pumpsie Green

1960 Topps #317 Pumpsie Green (ASR, RC)
 
Eating greens can have different meanings to different people. Many people enjoy collard greens (never had it myself), while others enjoy a nice green bean casserole (not me - do not like!). I'll convince myself I'm eating healthy with a nice salad to go along with all the good stuff. Pumpsie is famous for being the first black member of the Boston Red Sox - an embarrassing 12 years after Jackie Robinson broke baseball's color barrier.
 

Starting Pitcher - Spud Chandler

1971 Fleer World Series (Black Backs)
#41 1943 - Yankees vs. Cardinals
 
Sweet potatoes are great, but give me home made mashed potatoes with gravy any day! Spud was the A.L. MVP in 1943, the first right-handed pitcher to win the A.L. award since the BBWA voted for the award in 1931.
 

Relief Pitcher - Jimmy Gobble

2003 Donruss Studio #41 Jimmy Gobble
 
Seriously, how could this guy not make the list? Gobble was a left handed specialist, mainly for Kansas City from 2003-2009.
 

Manager - Chuck Dressen

1960 Topps #213 Chuck Dressen (MGR)
 
One last stalwart of Thanksgiving food would have to be the dressing/stuffing. Many people still cook it inside the turkey, but I prefer it baked by itself. Dressen was a long time manager, primarily known for his time with the Brooklyn Dodgers of the 40's and 50's. He won 2 World Series as a manager (1947 and 1959). 

It's your turn now! Can you think of any other Thanksgiving-related players? (There are plenty, I had a fun time narrowing down a list!)

No comments:

Post a Comment